On honest critical assessment of her physicals.
-
Archived from the IMDb Discussion Forums — Holly Marie Combs
pfarnell — 12 years ago(October 19, 2013 01:43 AM)
Shes striking looking, possibly facially more eye-catching than the other three, even though I drool over Milano ..
But, although a striking face, she is in the Amber Tamblyn genre..
ie,
eye-catching pretty -dragged back by a relatively homely body.
If she'd have worked out even a little upper body,where she is more than a little wanting,
it might have had a stunning effect .
Continually next to Milano in particular where all of them often are wearing sexy outfits such as Combs hot biker outfit in the Valkyrie episode,(where she is working with three guest model types with first class bodies)
accentuates this
Milano is all big boobs, gorgeous bare midriff and the rest lean muscle..
Next to that, Combs is just a little too yesteryear in muscle tone, small tits for her hip size, etc. -
katekelly — 12 years ago(November 18, 2013 09:39 PM)
Yikes. She is a gorgeous woman and in great shape! Especially now that she's older. Just because she doesn't have what YOU consider to be a perfect body doesn't mean she doesn't have a great body. They also dress her in Charmed to fit her character not to mention she was pregnant during parts of the show. Your post isn't an honest criticism, it's just your opinion. I hope you aren't so picky when it comes to the women in your life, for your sake and theirs. I'm not trying to offend you, that's really not my intention. It's just my honest opinion about your post.
-
pfarnell — 12 years ago(November 29, 2013 05:16 PM)
if you can give me a reason for asking, maybe.
I never said it was not my own assessment, didnt say it was enshrined in law, but I think its fair and measured having regard to her last couple of seasons of Charmed.
since posting that, Ive also read here that she has a thyroid condition which is not difficult to imagine how that keeps spiking her weight overall and keeps jacking distorting her shape and tone. -
MissAngelCakes — 12 years ago(March 22, 2014 10:38 AM)
That's what I love about Holly. She has a "normal" body. Alyssa's body is great, you can tell she works out a lot. But with Holly she has the natural womanly hips and curves. She looks different from all the other generic Hollywood types.
She's gorgeous. -
iplaygames2 — 11 years ago(January 02, 2015 04:08 AM)
Personally I liked the Piper character better than the other sisters (early and late seasons). I agree that Milano was rocking a more typical hot body look with the toned arms, flat stomach and large (albeit implanted) boobs. I just didn't care much for Milanos facial features, and particularly late in the series when she had the butch hair. I thought Holly always looked very womanly, admittedly more curvy than the others. I do agree that Combs was hotter in the early, younger years than in the late seasons. Further, I agree that some time in the gym would have done her some good. Personally, I liked the wider hips and regretted there weren't more shots of her arse on the show.
-
pfarnell — 10 years ago(December 29, 2015 02:20 PM)
and particularly late in the series when she had the butch hair. I thought Holly always looked very womanly, admittedly more curvy than the others.
I'd disagree re Milano's hairI think slicked-back shorter hair was one of the hottest looks, set off her facial bones..
Further, I agree that some time in the gym would have done her some good. Personally, I liked the wider hips and regretted there weren't more shots of her arse on the show.
as others have reminded, and I stipulated myself, an apparent medical issue re thyroid coming out of her pregnancy, made it more difficult or impossible for her to maintain toneher body was average when show started, but had blown out a litrle pear-shaped in late seasons obviously..she always lacked anything to compare with that hot arm-tone Milano had back there..would have been knock-out on her if she had it.
Oddly enough, despite the more homely body, she still looks great in jeans..for some reason, they suit her.Maybe there is some kind of country quality about her or something, i don't know.. -
tflynn-7 — 10 years ago(November 02, 2015 06:05 AM)
I agree with you. She has tremendous potential, but she squanders that by being lazy and not exercising. You can tell the rest of them take pride in the way they look but not Holly. She is fat and lazy(in my opinion) and does not deserve a TV or movie role. She is going to be a real pig by the time she is 50.
-
fraggle40 — 10 years ago(December 27, 2015 01:14 PM)
tflynn-7, you do know what happens when someone has an underactive thyroid, yes? They gain weight. Holly isn't "fat and lazy", she has a medical condition which isn't that easy to manage at all. At leas Holly will never be nasty and judgmental, unlike you.
I was gonna let you beep me, but I got my rag, and I know how you hate a mess