# 3 On My Top 10 Superhero Movie List…
-
Skibidido — 10 years ago(June 16, 2015 02:28 AM)
Interesting list. Thor 2 over the first? Batman Returns as the highest Batman movie? The Amazing Spiderman as the highest Spiderman movie? Very different taste from mine but respect for being original.
I dont have Watchmen quite in my top 10 but here goes:- The Dark Knight
- The Avengers
- Spider-man 2
- X2
- Batman Begins
- Guardians of the Galaxy
- Captain America: The Winter Soldier
- Iron Man
- The Dark Knight Rises
- X-men: Days of Future Past
-
russellnanamie — 10 years ago(July 10, 2015 01:44 PM)
I Loved both the film and the graphic novel. In fact Watchmen was the first comic book story that I ever read. I have to say that I cannot praise the wholly original graphic novel, Watchmen, enough. It elevated both itself and comic books as a whole to a much higher standing in literature. It is the standard in which all other comics should be compared and judged, a standard in which all other comics should strive for. That being said, while the film was amazing faithful to it's source, taboo of taboos the film did out due the original in at least one aspect.
I am referring to Ozymandias' Plot in which the film makes a substitution of the city destroying unknown alien threat for that of Doctor Manhattan's "Turn".
I found it more elegant and logical as well as more succinct in some way and that it coheres better with the rest of the story.
Watchmen currently ranks #2 on my list, entitled
Super-Hero Movies, the best and the worst
.
I am afraid we differ quite a lot, based on your top 10 selection.
www.imdb.com/list/ls008449809
But here is a link to my list of over a 100 comic book movies and super-hero movies, in order from mind blowing all the way to why is this even a movie, oh and spoiler alert Catwoman isn't the worst, hard to believe though it may be.