Saw it yesterday, quite dark and gritty - to be expected but I enjoyed it, had some great visuals, fun set pieces all wi
-
Archived from the IMDb Discussion Forums — Sports
NightShadeAlleluia — 9 years ago(December 18, 2016 07:16 AM)
Saw it yesterday, quite dark and gritty - to be expected but I enjoyed it, had some great visuals, fun set pieces all without Jedi but one Sith in Vader, who had some pretty great scenes.
Solid cast, Donnie Yen was awesome, Alan Tudyk was great as K2SO and Felicity Jones was surprisingly good, thought she came across as a bit flat in the trailers.
Tldr - An actually good Star wars prequel, good acting and a good contained story.
What's up white people.
http://docthewho.wordpress.com/- check my blog
-
Rey_Kahuka — 9 years ago(December 18, 2016 08:57 AM)
I think it might be the best Star Wars movie ever. That world felt lived in. There were stakes to everything. I loved watching people go about their business in that city until things got turned sideways by the insurgents. It just felt
real
. Going on location in Iceland is as far away from Lucas' digital world prequel nonsense as you can get.
Then you had the planet with the massive overturned monoliths on the ground, the art direction in this flick was incredible. It's always great to see different style troopers and vehicles as well.
The story was excellent and the characters had depth.
I assumed going in that they were all going to die, it only occurred to me after the fact that it would've been easy to keep some of them alive for future installments. This is the biggest film franchise in history and they had the balls to kill off every major character in the story. These people fought the good fight and paid the price. In war, even central characters are killed. As a fan of film I'm proud of the creative team for making that bold choice.
I'm going to see it again at some point before it leaves theaters, it's worth repeat viewings on the big screen.
The future is in the hands of a man who has none.
(As in no future, as opposed to no hands.) -
Roger_Sterling — 9 years ago(December 18, 2016 09:14 PM)
Agreed. Art direction was amazing and Jyn was a strong female character that didn't feel forced, and you actually gave a sh-t when the characters died.
Vader sounded strange, but you really can't expect anything different considering JEJ is pushing 90. -
Pops_Is_Your_Daddy — 9 years ago(December 18, 2016 10:08 PM)
I need to see it again. The f^cking good-for-nothing theater where I saw it on Saturday night didn't mask the image properly, so I watched the whole thing with the tops of characters' heads cut off and God-knows-what other missing visual information.
That said, I have mixed feelings on the film after seeing it once. I thought the first half was incredibly cumbersome. A clunky narrative punctuated by some fun call-backs and imaginative production design. Everything up to
Jyn's reunion with her father
was, I thought, very choppily executed, and I had to resist rolling my eyes at the speechifying that would happen in every other scene.
So coming out of the above-mentioned event, which was a really terrific sequence overall, I was relatively indifferent to the film. It had some promising fits and starts, but never really strung together sufficient momentum to elicit more than a shrug.
And then the last 45 minutes happened.
I don't think I've seen more striking, beautiful images on a movie theater screen this year (and remember: I wasn't even
seeing the images as they were intended to be seen
). It's a breathtaking third act, and is absolutely the reason I'll pony up for another go while the film is still in theaters. Giacchino's score really worked some magic in that section as well.
So: I'd recommend Rogue One, but it's an imperfect beast.
By Grabthar's Hammerwhat a savings. -
pankoeken — 9 years ago(December 18, 2016 11:43 PM)
I seem to recall that heroine escaping using jedi mind tricks that she somehow mastered in seconds despite not knowing what a jedi mind trick was much less ever receiving the most basic instruction in how to trick a mind the jedi way.
Hell an 80's style training montage or scene of the chick watching a hologram video entitled "Mastering the Force for Dummies" would have been better than "Tee hee I'm the most powerful person in the universe no explanation needed because star wars fanboys are actually that simple minded tee hee" -
jimanchower — 9 years ago(December 19, 2016 12:03 AM)
I think they're going to reveal more of her backstory in the next film.
Maybe she has had training?
TFA was good, my problems with it were it was basically a remake of the first and the characters acted a little too 2016 Planet Earth as opposed to Star Warsy IMO.
I enjoyed it but I hope in the next one they do something new. -
HeHatesShe — 9 years ago(December 19, 2016 12:11 AM)
But you said she defeated everyone in seconds.
She did not. She was knocked out and captured.
"Shes not a Mary Sue, said Trump. She was a Mary Sue because she was captured. I like people who werent captured. -
Rocketman — 9 years ago(December 19, 2016 12:26 AM)
I really enjoyed the majority of the movie. I felt some of the actions scenes were hampered by them always cutting away to show what was happening elsewhere (which is becoming quite a problem with movies these days). I would've loved to have seen the shot where Jyn and the rest of Rogue Squadron are charging out of that tunnel while evading the AT-AT's blasters that was in the first teaser trailer back in April.
It wasn't as good as Force Awakens (which is the second best Star Wars movie IMO) but it still had great scenes like Vader's scene at the end, the battle on Jedha and
the Death Star blowing up the Imperial Archive while Jyn and Cassian sit on the beach and have a moment together before being incinerated
. I loved how the movie looked like a very gritty and "grounded" version of Star Wars and how everything looked like it came straight from the 70s/80s.
I kind of wish we get more of these kinds of Star Wars movies where they focus on the actual Wars aspect of Star Wars, and maybe even make a live action version of the Clone Wars. -
NightShadeAlleluia — 9 years ago(December 19, 2016 02:52 AM)
Actually focusing on the war was a great idea and brought a grounded feeling to things, we always see Troopers or rebels getting shot and think nothing of it but now we saw them up close and it and knew some of them.
The visuals were great as well,
the Jeddha destruction scene with the debris going into space was incredible, never seen anything like that in Star Wars, same with
corvette ramming the Star Destroyer, I love seeing things brand new in SW so yeah, more of that!
What's up white people.
http://docthewho.wordpress.com/- check my blog
-
-
HollywoodWolfman1 — 9 years ago(December 20, 2016 11:55 AM)
I thought it was quite good, particularly the 3rd act. Surprised how great the visuals were, considering in Edwards' last film you could barely see anything at all.
Considerably better than The Force Awakens in my opinion. Outside of the nostalgia of seeing Ford and others in old roles, I honestly didn't really see what people liked about that one so much. Thought it was just adequate entertainment that was hampered by a few poor performances (especially a horrific Boyega) and a miscast Oscar Issac. (I love Issac, but he's the last guy I would cast as an enthusiastically optimistic hero type) -
jharmon64 — 9 years ago(December 21, 2016 06:22 AM)
Gotta tell you, I can barely remember the last one it was so ordinary.
Feel like I'd better watch that one again first.
No way I'll see it in the theater, luckily that's what I did last time around.
Relax, all right? My old man is a TV repairman, he's got this ultimate set of tools. I can fix it! -
Ghost_Reveries — 9 years ago(December 21, 2016 02:13 PM)
Finally got to see it Monday night. It made me want to revisit my copies of the original trilogy on Blu-ray. Not the best Star Wars by any means, but certainly not the worst. The ending battle scenes are worth the price of admission alone. 8/10
-
ur53486799 — 9 years ago(December 22, 2016 06:26 AM)
I went the other night with my brother. Both forty-somethings raised on Star Wars, huge fans in our childhood and still retain a certain loyalty to the franchise despite the prequels.
Anyway, I thought it was bloody marvellous - genuinely hugely better than I was anticipating - and he was pissed off at how underwhelmed he was. So make of that what you will.