Ghost in the tunnel and the escape.
-
Archived from the IMDb Discussion Forums — American Horror Story
elisapena89 — 9 years ago(October 27, 2016 12:20 PM)
In the last reenactment episode all four of them escape because the own clan attacked the Butcher. So why are they helping her again? Thought her own clan didn't like the Butcher and had turned on her?
Also the ghost in the tunnel was nice we'll maybe not nice but wasn't trying to kill them to Shelby and Matt and showed them the way out of the tunnel. This time however, he didn't seem too friendly with the 3 ladies.
Last are all the Butchers victims angry ghost now? Are they out for blood? -
Benjen_Snark — 9 years ago(October 27, 2016 12:23 PM)
It's possible that what Shelby and Matt said in the original MRN was a lie about the colonists turning on the Butcher.
It's also possible that the colonists forgave the Butcher, and she them.
It's also possible that the writers forgot all about that because they needed angry colonist ghosts to help the butcher do her butchering in RTN. -
WinkerAugusta — 9 years ago(October 27, 2016 12:26 PM)
Perhaps Lee, Matt, and Shelby were not honest about their final getaway.
Perhaps Ambrose will once again rebel.
It is strange that Shelby tells Matt there is no way - when she escaped before.
If fire worked before - why not try to set The Butcher on fire?
Re: Why did Matt and Shelby lie about Edward Mott?
Matt seemed to know more about Mott in real lifd than he conveyed in his interview.
Lee says "Matt thinks that he prefers the tunnel."
When Lee says this to Monet and Audrey - they seemed surprised to not know this information.
Lee's statement makes it seem as though Matt more interaction with Mott than just the escape.
Why would Matt and Shelby leave these details out?
Matt says that their marriage was over when they moved into Sappony. Was Matt sleeping in the basement most of the time and not with Shelby? Was Matt with The Witch in the basement multiple times (the one time conscious interaction in the cellar never took place - Matt lied and told the story that way along with Shelby)?