This message has been deleted.
-
PiStAcHiO_NuT — 21 years ago(February 03, 2005 10:03 AM)
It's all fair and good, i can't comment cos i haven't read the other book however, from what you say, it's not that big a steal by Garland, an infection leads to zombiefication (if thats a word). but the whole film is takled pretty damn well i thought, and it pretty much fullfilled Garlands intention to portray the UK as a pretty pathetically paranoid island, which it probably is, seeming as we seem to think everyone is after us, particularly terrorists n stuff. I can't imagine you'd get much support for that2000 criticism, it's pretty weak seeming as (from what you described) the stories arent that majorly parallel, infact it seems the only similarity is the fact that a loada people get infected- shrugs
-
therRhetor — 21 years ago(February 04, 2005 06:23 PM)
Cheese, it's really not that far-fetched that Garland came up with the idea on his own and the two just happen to be similar.
While driving in the car 8 months before 28 days later ever came out, I told my friend I wanted to write a screenplay about the havoc wrecked on society when a disease mysteriously spread that turned everyone into a raging beast with no regard for right/wrong. This is pretty much the exact premise of 28 Days Later and by no means did I steal it from Garland.
It's just a good idea, and sometimes several people see the same good idea and take advantage of it.
Stop being such a snob. -
Laguna1284 — 20 years ago(June 10, 2005 08:28 PM)
Wow, dude. I'm actually a big fan of both I Am Legend and 28 Days Later, and they really are nothing alike. You want to see what a movie version of I Am Legend looks like go watch The Omega Man. But really, did you actually read or watch either of them, respectively? They aren't even close to being similar, so much so that I honestly feel I don't have to back up my statement.
-
5minutemike — 20 years ago(June 12, 2005 03:56 PM)
i agree, i love both stories, along with anything by alex garland, though there may be a few similarities they are nothing alike. you could make a better case in that the 28 days story is much more like Earth Abides by George R. Stewert. Same type of thing happens minus the zombies. and it focus' alot more on the rebuilding of society.